Episode 190: Is That Strategy Really Not Working — Or Is It Context? | End-of-Year Reflection

You see a 60-second classroom video on social media. Students are engaged, speaking, producing. And you go straight to: "That is not happening in my class. Something is wrong with me."

But you're missing the other 44 minutes — the class size, the school, the context behind that clip.

In this episode, Claudia sits down with world language teacher Dahiana Castro to talk about something our profession doesn't say enough: every strategy has to meet your context. That's not a limitation — that's good teaching.

This is not about lowering expectations. Your students can and do grow. But a strategy that works with 15 motivated students in a selective program will likely need real adaptation for a class of 37 in an under-resourced public school — and making that call is a valid, professional decision.

In this episode:

• Why that viral classroom video is missing more context than you think
• The real factors that shape whether a strategy succeeds
• How to adapt strategies for your actual students — not the ideal ones
• Why blanket statements like "if you do X, students will do Y" ignore real classroom complexity
• How to reflect at year's end without the shame spiral

The goal isn't to replicate what you saw online. It's to ask: how can this work here, with these students?

🔗 Resources & Links:

• 📋 Free reflection resource + student survey: growingwithproficiency.com/reflection
• Join the waitlist for Growing With Proficiency: The Spanish Teacher Academy
• Follow Claudia on Instagram @claudiamelliott
• Growing With CI FB Community
• Blog
• Teacher Pay Teachers Store